Ceteris Lab Open the lab

Portfolio choice and CAPM

How much risk is worth how much return? Mix investments, discover which risks earn a return, and try to turn a fictional $1 million into $3 million over twenty years.

The big lessonCombining investments can remove company-specific risk. Market risk remains, and a higher expected return does not guarantee that you reach your goal.

One goal. Three ways to begin.

Start with $1 million at age 40. The goal is $2.8 million at 60. Try the first five years of one simulated history.

Wealth over the first five years for three starting plans, with the reference path to the goal

Reference path to the goal: the growth that reaches the goal by 60, not an expected path.

Wealth after five years
$0.99M
Change from the start
−0.6%

With the stock and bond funds, $1,000,000 became $0.99M after five years of this history (−0.6%).

In this history T-bills alone finished the five years ahead. One history is not a forecast: play another, and the same choice can turn out differently.

The News

Year 5 · age 45Ordinary year

An ordinary year. Stocks returned −3.0%; bonds +5.8%.

Riverbend Utilities loses a major lawsuit: RVBU returned −37%. It is 5.9% of your money: −2.2 points from its own news.

  • Safe-rate baseline +3.0 points
  • Market moves −2.7 points (the stock and bond markets)
  • Company and bond news −4.2 points

Your wealth: −3.9%, to $0.99M.

The five years in numbers
Year (age)Market returnT-bills onlyStocks and bondsOne stock
1 (41)−1.2%$1.03M$1.05M$1.18M
2 (42)−25.4%$1.06M$0.88M$0.39M
3 (43)+11.9%$1.09M$0.99M$0.50M
4 (44)−11.2%$1.13M$1.04M$0.05M
5 (45)−3.0%$1.16M$0.99M$0.06M

Fictional assets and simulated returns from the Portfolio teaching model. One possible history, not a forecast. Play the full twenty years (a new game starts at the plan).

Can a mix be safer than either investment?

Two investments do not always rise and fall together. Change the mix and see how its expected return and volatility change. Volatility is the size of the ups and downs in returns, measured here by their standard deviation.

40%

All in Northern Bond FundAll in Aurora Tech

Expected return
7.9%
Volatility
14.9%

With 40% in Aurora Tech and 60% in Northern Bond Fund, the mix expects 7.9% a year with volatility 14.9%: riskier than Northern Bond Fund alone (8.9%), in exchange for a higher expected return.

Northern Bond Fund is a risky bond fund, not the safe T-bill.

Expected return against volatility for every mix of Aurora Tech and Northern Bond Fund

These are model expectations, not the five-year outcomes above. The mix changes the risks you carry; a particular market history decides the result you actually get. Explore Your Portfolio to choose other pairs, change the correlation and try short sales.

Which risk earns a return?

The Capital Asset Pricing Model, or CAPM, links an investment's required return to its exposure to the market. Diversification can remove company-specific risk; the CAPM predicts how much return an investment should offer for the market risk that remains. Click each part.

Required return

E[Rᵢ] = r_f + βᵢ (E[R_M] − r_f)

Beta βᵢ

How strongly the investment follows the market: its sensitivity to market returns, not its total volatility. A beta of one does not make an investment the market itself.

In this economy (Aurora Tech)
1.80

For Aurora Tech: 3% + 1.80 × 6% = 13.8% a year.

ARTK Aurora Tech

Volatility
35.4%
Beta
1.80
Required return
13.8%

PGLD Polar Gold

Volatility
34.7%
Beta
0.20
Required return
4.2%

Almost the same volatility, very different market sensitivity, so very different required returns: the CAPM pays for market risk only. CAPM is a benchmark for required returns. Realized returns can differ, and real data need not fit the model. Open CAPM for alpha, price adjustment and the evidence illustration, or Risk & Beta for where beta comes from.

5 pages, one question each.

  1. Your Portfolio What changes when you combine two investments?
  2. The Market Which portfolios offer the most return for their risk?
  3. Risk & Beta Which risks disappear when you diversify?
  4. CAPM What return should an investment offer for its market exposure?
  5. Retire Early Can your plan reach its goal through twenty uncertain years?

What the model takes as given.

Assets
Fictional
A teaching economy of six made-up companies whose expectations satisfy the CAPM by construction. No historical market data are used.
Safe rate
3%
The T-bill return, certain, a year.
Market
9% expected, 16% volatility
A market premium of 6% a year above the safe rate.
Retire Early
Nominal dollars, yearly steps
No contributions, withdrawals or inflation. The market fund rebalances each year; your plan is reviewed every five.
The preview
One history
A single simulated history; the full game's other histories describe the simulation, not anyone's personal finances.

Theory

  • Markowitz (1952) · “Portfolio Selection”, Journal of Finance.
  • Sharpe (1964) · “Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk”, Journal of Finance.
  • University course notes · Undergraduate financial economics lectures on portfolio choice and the CAPM.

Try your plan through twenty uncertain years.